« Misdiagnosis of Persistent Vegetative State | Main | Maria Korp sentenced to death »

July 25, 2005

Disability Activists Blast PBS for ADA Anniversary Promotion of 'Better Dead than Disabled' Film

Topics: Press Releases

Forest Park, IL, July 25, 2005 -- In an all-too-common feat of cultural insensitivity, PBS has chosen July 26th, the anniversary of the signing of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) to air "POV: The Self-Made Man." The documentary features the videotaped statements of Bob Stern, an elderly man deciding to commit suicide rather than face possible disability, medical uncertainly or complications.

"The choice of this particular air date is an affront to people with disabilities in this country," says Diane Coleman, president of Not Dead Yet, a national disability rights group based in Forest Park, IL. "It's the 15th anniversary of the signing of the ADA, a law that is, for people with disabilities, the nation's largest minority, what the Civil Rights Act of 1964 is for people of color. Not only is this being ignored by PBS, but the network is featuring and promoting a program about a person so terrified of aging and disability that he commits suicide. In terms of sensitivity to diversity issues, this puts PBS in the same league as the Fox News Channel. And, no, that is not a compliment."

Stephen Drake, research analyst for Not Dead Yet, notes that the film is a slanted portrayal of the broader issues. "Normally, we don't comment when a rich, privileged guy decides to take his own life. We didn't comment when Hunter Thompson shot himself. After all, Thompson wasn't asking for a change in the law, a permission slip, or help from anyone."

Drake says the situation is different with "The Self-Made Man." "It's being promoted as a tool for adding to the public discourse in regard to assisted suicide, an issue confronting the U.S. Supreme Court and legislators in California. Whether society will treat some suicidal people differently than others is a public policy issue. The film, however, frames the issue as a dispute between religious conservatives and those who "believe in autonomy."

Coleman and Drake say this ignores the fact that secular disability rights groups have been at the forefront of opposing legalization of assisted suicide. Twelve national disability groups filed an amicus brief supporting the Attorney General in the Gonzalez v. Oregon case currently before the Supreme Court.

Moreover, disability opposition is well known to the official "advisors" to the documentary. Three out of the four credited advisors to the program are long-time assisted suicide/euthanasia advocates: Paul Spiers, former board Chair of "Compassion and Choices;" Margaret Battin, advisory board member of the Death with Dignity National Center; and Dennis Kuby, former regional director (California) of the Hemlock Society. These "advisors" could have advised a truthful portrayal of the policy debate, including disability opposition. "Obviously, balance is one thing producer Susan Stern wasn't looking for," says Drake.

Source: Not Dead Yet, HT: Open Book

Posted by tim at July 25, 2005 10:44 AM

Articles Related to Press Releases:


Korp's feeding tube 'to be removed'
11:00 AEST Tue Jul 26 2005
National Nine News
Woman-in-the-boot victim Maria Korp is to have her feeding tube removed and will "die like a dog", according to her brother-in-law.
Mrs Korp, 50, has been in a permanent vegetative state in Melbourne’s Alfred Hospital since she was found unconscious and locked in the boot of her car in February.

Mrs Korp’s husband, Joe, has been charged with conspiracy to murder and intentionally causing serious injury to his wife.

Korp's brother, Gust, told Melbourne radio 3AW Joe had been informed of the decision today by his solicitors.

"They contacted Joe and they said: 'They're removing the feed from your wife'."

Although he had not seen the letter, Gust Korp said: "It's fact. Joe's confirmed it. He's rang his solicitor's again saying 'can you please read the letter again'.

"Today is the day that (Public Advocate) has decided that Maria Korp will no longer receive any more feed.

"And we're just going to let her die like a dog without food."

Joe Korp's former lover, Tania Herman, 38, was sentenced to a minimum nine years' jail last month after pleading guilty to the attempted murder.

Mrs Korp, a mother of two, was found near Melbourne's Shrine of Remembrance on February 13, four days after she was attacked in the garage of the Korps' home.

The Office of the Public Advocate, which is Mrs Korp's legal guardian, is expected to make a statement on the matter this afternoon.

National Nine News

Posted by: Maggie4Life at July 25, 2005 10:54 PM

As a follow up to the Korp story, Maria passed away today. You can find the news here:


Posted by: Maggie4Life [TypeKey Profile Page] at August 4, 2005 8:26 PM

More rubbish from PBS.

Posted by: thedegu [TypeKey Profile Page] at September 6, 2005 1:30 PM