« CWA Responds to Schiavo Autopsy Report: No Excuses for Dehydrating the Disabled | Main | Charlotte Wyatt and the debate about infant intervention »


June 15, 2005

LifesiteNews on Terri's Autopsy Report

Topics:

LARGO, FL., June 15, 2005 (LifeSiteNews.com) - At a news conference held at 11:00 a.m. today the Florida medical examiner released the results of the autopsy performed on Terri Schiavo, performed after her high-profile court-ordered execution resulted in her death on March 31 of this year.

The results of the autopsy were highly anticipated given many unanswered questions around the controversial case, especially the unknown cause of her initial collapse in 1990. Schiavo's parents and siblings have often alleged, throughout their decade long battle to protect Terri from the fatal wishes of her legal husband, that Terri was being abused at the time of her collapse, and that asphyxiation by strangulation may have been the immediate cause of her condition.

These suspicions seemed to gain some credence after Terri's death when her husband Michael Schiavo asked that an autopsy not be performed on Terri and that he would cremate her body. Throughout the case Shiavo's motivations were repeatedly questioned on account of a million dollar insurance payout, as well as the fact that he has been living with another woman for some years with whom he has had two children. In the end, however, Schiavo chose to 'permit' the autopsy, though it was subsequently discovered that he had no say in the matter.

Terri mourners have been skeptical that an autopsy almost fifteen years after Terri's collapse could reveal conclusive evidence of abuse. Terri's family, however, had hoped to achieve some sort of closure on the possible cause of what remains a mysterious and inexplicable illness. Today, the possibility of such closure seems to have permanently slipped from their hands.

Media coverage of Medical Examiner Jon Thogmartin's autopsy results thus far has almost exclusively centered on two assertions: 1) No evidence for abuse could be discovered on Terri's body, and 2) Terri's brain was 'severely atrophied', or approximately half the weight that it should have been at the time of her death. Many, including the Examiner, are pointing to this as evidence that Terri was permanently brain dead and are again using the "permanent vegetative state", or PVS phrase which has commonly been used by mainstream media to dehumanize Shiavo. Terri's supporters have instead characterized her as being "cognitively disabled".

An impossible to determine PVS diagnosis based upon the findings of the autopsy was predicted by many neurologists. In a March 31 article in MedPage Today, Dr. Michael De Georgia, head of the neurology/neurosurgery intensive care unit at the Cleveland Clinic Foundation, warned his readers against a PVS diagnosis, saying that it "cannot be confirmed by autopsy." Dr. Mouhammed Kabbani, a neurologist at the University of Missouri, concurred, saying "an autopsy can show the degree of brain damage and how much brain tissue survived the injury", but that "it cannot by any means tell about the patient's clinical status."

Fr. Frank Pavone, who was with Terri in her dying moments has responded to this assertion from the moral standpoint saying that "A person with a 'profoundly atrophied' brain needs profound care and love. Terri did not die from an atrophied brain. She died from an atrophy of compassion on the part of her estranged husband and those who helped him to have her deliberately killed."

It is also not clear how much of the damage to Terri's brain may have been caused by the extended period of starvation and dehydration which was the final cause of her death, and which reduced her entire body to a mere shadow of its formal self.

However, the unsubstantiated claim put forward by Schiavo and many of the courts, that Terri had suffered from an 'eating disorder' around the time of her collapse, was not given any credit by the medical examiner.

Fr. Pavone summed up the attitude of those who regarded Terri's death as an avoidable tragedy, the result of a so-called 'right-to-die' agenda which engulfed and ultimately ended Terri's life, and which she was unable to defend herself against due to her medical condition. "No details of this autopsy change the moral evaluation of what happened to Terri," said Pavone. "Her physical injuries and disabilities never made her less of a person. No amount of brain injury ever justifies denying a person proper humane care. That includes food and water."

Source: LifeSiteNews

Posted by tim at June 15, 2005 9:11 PM


Articles Related to :

Comments

It is inaccurate to claim that Terri was brain dead. If she had been brain dead she would not have lasted for 15 years.

Someone brought it to my attention that Terri's brain was affected by the dehydration. I think that is a very feasible explanation of why her brain was at a smaller size than Karen Quinlan.

Posted by: Maggie4life at June 17, 2005 5:56 AM